Skip to content

Stress

A coating pulls on the part it is deposited on. If the substrate is thin enough the part bends; if the film stores enough energy it cracks, or lets go of what is under it. Stress predicts all three from the constants on your materials and four numbers about the run.

No stress model is as good as the optical one. Film stress depends on the deposition process, not only on the material, so the constants are yours to measure, and the numbers compare one design against another rather than predict a part in absolute terms.

Stress

Every constant comes off the Mechanical tab of the Material Editor. A constant nobody entered leaves the rows that need it blank, and the notice badge names the material and the field.

Quantity What it is Needs
Film stress biaxial stress in each film, tensile positive intrinsic stress; with temperatures set, also modulus, Poisson’s ratio, expansion coefficients and reference temperature, each thermal term left out where its constant is missing
Strain energy elastic energy one film stores per unit area stress, modulus, Poisson’s ratio
Delamination energy of a film and everything outside it against the surface energy of the interface below; at 1 there is the energy to let go strain energies, surface energy of both materials
Total strain energy sum over the films every strain energy
Cracking parameter ∑U/2γ\sum U / 2\gamma; at 1 the stack can pay for the two faces of a crack every strain energy and surface energy
Film force ∑σ⋅d\sum \sigma \cdot d, what Stoney’s equation turns into a bow, and what the STR merit row targets every film’s stress (none stated counts as none)
Edge shear peak shear at the rim of the coating stresses, moduli and Poisson’s ratios of the coating and substrate, substrate thickness
Radius of curvature positive for the convex face a compressive coating leaves film force, substrate modulus, Poisson’s ratio, thickness
Centre deflection bow of the centre against the rim, positive convex the radius and the substrate diameter

The chart is a bar per film in its material’s color, tensile up and compressive down; films are numbered 1 at the substrate. Delamination usually peaks at the substrate interface, which is where a coating does let go. Under a uniform stress the shear is zero inside the coating and rises only at its edge, which is why coatings fail from the rim inward.

T: the temperature the part is at when you read the stress. T deposition: the temperature of the substrate while the films grow, what the thermocouple or pyrometer on the planet reads, not the temperature of the evaporant. Leave both empty and every film carries its intrinsic stress; set either and both apply, the other reading 20 °C.

Substrate d: the thickness, the same value the Design Editor carries. The bow goes as one over its square, so it is the strongest lever in the window. Substrate ⌀: the diameter, for the centre deflection only. All four are saved with the design.

Which coatings count follows the design’s evaluation mode. With coatings on both faces the two bending moments oppose, so the force is Ffront−FbackF_\text{front} - F_\text{back}, and a mirrored back coating cancels the bow exactly. A coating on one face reads the same on the back as on the front.

Environment: on a design with more than one environment, Current follows the environment the Design Editor shows and a numbered one holds the window on it even while it is switched off. The films and substrate are the ones that environment computes with, and with temperatures set T moves by the environment’s temperature less environment 1’s. A field the environment changes shows the value it computes with and is not edited here. The choice is not saved with the design.

A film force of zero is the zero-deflection condition. Put an STR row with a target of 0 in the Merit Function Editor and the optimizer balances the stack; see Operands for how to weight it.

A film condenses strain free at its own deposition temperature, then takes the substrate’s temperature without changing its lateral size, the intrinsic strain; σref\sigma_\text{ref} is that stress for a film deposited at the material’s reference temperature TrefT_\text{ref}. From there to TT the film follows the substrate and the expansion mismatch adds:

σ=σref+E1−ν⋅[αf(Tref−Tdep)+(αs−αf)(T−Tdep)]\sigma = \sigma_\text{ref} + \frac{E}{1 - \nu} \cdot \left[ \alpha_f \left(T_\text{ref} - T_\text{dep}\right) + (\alpha_s - \alpha_f) \left(T - T_\text{dep}\right) \right]

The force, the curvature (Stoney, Klein 2001 Eq. 26) and the centre deflection of a disc of radius r0r_0:

F=∑σldlK=6FEs′ts2,Es′=Es1−νs,R=−1Kω0=−1−cos⁡Kr0K≈−r02K2\begin{aligned} F &= \sum \sigma_l d_l \\ K &= \frac{6F}{E'_s t_s^2}, \qquad E'_s = \frac{E_s}{1 - \nu_s}, \qquad R = -\frac{1}{K} \\ \omega_0 &= -\frac{1 - \cos K r_0}{K} \approx -\frac{r_0^2 K}{2} \end{aligned}

The energies (Klokholm 1987, Eqs. 1, 2 and 6), with γ\gamma the surface energy and film jj’s interface below it shared with film j−1j - 1 or the substrate:

Ul=σl2 dl(1−νl)Elcracking=∑lUl2γldelamj=∑l≥jUlγj+γj−1\begin{aligned} U_l &= \frac{\sigma_l^2\, d_l (1 - \nu_l)}{E_l} \\ \text{cracking} &= \sum_l \frac{U_l}{2\gamma_l} \\ \text{delam}_j &= \frac{\sum_{l \ge j} U_l}{\gamma_j + \gamma_{j-1}} \end{aligned}

The edge shear at the interface below film jj (Klein 2001 Eqs. 8 and 25), FjF_j the force of film jj and everything outside it:

k=32Es/((1+νs)ts)∑lEldl/(1−νl2)τmax=k⋅∣Fj∣\begin{aligned} k &= \sqrt{\frac{\tfrac{3}{2} E_s / \left((1 + \nu_s) t_s\right)}{\sum_l E_l d_l / (1 - \nu_l^2)}} \\ \tau_\text{max} &= k \cdot |F_j| \end{aligned}

1/k1/k is the width of the strip at the rim that carries the shear.

  • E. Klokholm, “Intrinsic stress in evaporated metal films,” IBM J. Res. Dev. 31, 585 (1987): the strain-energy criteria for cracking and delamination.
  • E. Suhir, “Predicted thermally induced stresses in, and the bow of, a circular substrate/thin-film structure,” J. Appl. Phys. 88, 2363 (2000).
  • C. A. Klein, “How accurate are Stoney’s equation and recent modifications,” J. Appl. Phys. 88, 5487 (2000).
  • C. A. Klein, “Normal and interfacial stresses in thin-film coated optics: the case of diamond-coated zinc sulfide windows,” Opt. Eng. 40, 1115 (2001): the interface forces, the curvature and the zero-deflection condition.